RESOURCES

diane bowser's
virtual office

Guide Questions:

Introduction to  Postmodernism

Baudrillard

Lyotard

Spivak

Week 5 Notes:

The following notes are highlights from the above chapter. They are neither intended to replace the lectures and text, nor to substitute for a reading of the text. Lectures will add to and supplement material given here. In order to do well in this class, it is recommended that you review these notes to identify main ideas after having attended class.

Reading philosophical essays is more challenging in that you often have to scan once, read once, and review once before you can adequately explain the author's position. In order to be sure that you are receiving maximum benefit from your time spent studying, try to answer the guide questions posed below. If you cannot answer them, it is time to read or review to be sure you understand the main arguments presented.

What is postmodernism?

One must begin the discussion of postmodernism by discussing modernity before the 20th century. Modern ideals begin appearing in the works of Descartes and end in the obtuse prose of Hegel.  To sum, modernism is a philosophical movement characterized by its investigations of space-time, consciousness, and being. In each case modern philosophers searched for the foundations underlying each idea and then strove to communicate "first principles" for axiology, epistemology and metaphysics. During the modern period so-called foundationalists were looking for unifying principles that could ground the most basic questions posed in each branch of philosophical study.  Each modern philosopher began his major works by exploring the work that had preceded him and then set out to explain how various approaches to axiology, epistemology or metaphysics might be explained by one central idea.  For example, in the case of axiology (ethics) Kant argues that the categorical imperative is the ultimate weapon for solving all ethical disputes.

After the advent of WWII, successive generations of ethicists have not been similarly convinced. Some philosophers regard Marx as the first postmodern thinker because they believe historical materialism is the first historically situated attempt at explaining the differences in ethical reasoning. Most, however, might bestow the title "first postmodernist" on Nietzsche because he wholeheartedly rejects the foundationalist assumption that metaphysics can be unified under one Platonic principle. The postmodernists we will reading also reject the idea that there will be absolute principles grounding any particular branch of philosophy.

top

Latest Links ò
Notes

Foucault: Day 1

Derrida

Lacan - Kristeva

Post-structuralism and Post-Modern Theory

Russell's Philosophy for Laymen

Resource Links for this week's assignment:

Pages devoted to postmodern thought: these are the same resources I listed on our poststructuralist notes page.

Baudrillard:

Lyotard:

Spivak

 

top

Guide Questions:

The following questions are designed to fine tune your understanding of the reading. Although I will not collect or check to see if you've completed them, the subject matter and answers to these questions form the basis of what you will be required to know for exams.

Introductory Reading:

  1. What are the two main narratives characterizing post-modernism?(174)

  2. List three ways that the term "postmodern" is used. (176)

  3. List three of Hassan's methods for distinguishing between modernism and post-modernism.(177)

  4. What is the summarizing theme of postmodernism?(178)

  5. How is irony used in post-modern fiction(179)

Baudrillard

  1. What is hyper-reality?(180)

  2. What is the status of the real in a world dominated by images?(180)

  3. Describe Baudrillard's theory concerning imagery and the Gulf War.(180-181)

  4. How does Norris refute Baudrillard?(181)

Lyotard

  1. What is a totalizing narrative?(182)

  2. What does Lyotard mean when he states that the grand narrative of the Enlightenment lacks credibility?(183)

  3. When post-modern science loses its anchor, what happens?(184)

  4. How do breakthroughs happen in post-modern science?(184)

  5. If post-modern ethics generates its answers in response to particular criteria, could we not conceive of it as a contemporary form of utilitarianism?(184-185)

Spivak

  1. What is Spivak's primary method of analysis?(193)

  2. What is the relationship between a thinker who deconstructs an idea and the idea under consideration?(193)

  3. Who is Spivak making reference to with the term "subaltern?"(194)

  4. How does a deconstruction of the idea of power alter the educational landscape?(195) Are all narratives equally worthy of educational time?

  5. How might we characterize the effects of post-modern critique on the academy and social institutions?(195-197)

top

home space | calendar | e-mail instructor | notes | syllabus

Last Updated 04 March, 2000 08:49 PM

All materials (C) diane bowser. Users may not use content, images or designs on this page to create a for-profit publication.